Find your code

Repair vs Replace Calculator

Enter the appliance age, its expected lifespan, the repair quote and the price of a new unit to see whether the fix is worth it under the 50 percent rule.

By ApplianceCodeHQ Editorial Updated

Clear the form

Fill in the fields: the result appears under the form.

How it works

Repair share = repair estimate ÷ new unit price × 100; life used = age ÷ expected lifespan × 100

The calculator applies a common rule of thumb, often called the 50 percent rule: when an appliance has used more than half of its expected life and the repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new unit, replacing it usually makes more sense. Below both halves, a repair is usually the better deal. The repair-cost half matches Consumer Reports' advice not to spend more than half the price of a new product on a repair; the age half is a common extension, not a standard. Example: a 6-year-old washer with an expected life of 12 years, a $180 repair quote and a $1,000 new price — the repair is 18 % of a new unit and half of its life is used, so repair it: the quote is $320 below the $500 limit.

For the expected lifespan, use the figure your technician, the manufacturer or the retailer gives for your type of appliance; the calculator does not assume one for you. For the new price, use a model with similar features and capacity, not the cheapest one on the shelf.

Reading the result
Life usedRepair shareUsually
Under 50 % Under 50 % Repair
Under 50 % Over 50 % Get a second quote, weigh the warranty
Over 50 % Under 50 % Repair if the rest of the appliance is in good shape
Over 50 % Over 50 % Replace

Frequently asked questions

Is the 50 percent rule always right?

No — it is a starting point. A warranty, a repair that fixes a part that rarely fails twice, or a much more efficient new model can all tip the decision.

Should I count the service call fee?

Yes. Enter the full repair estimate, including the diagnostic or service call fee and the parts.

What if the appliance is still under warranty?

Check the warranty first: a covered repair costs you little or nothing, which makes repairing the obvious choice.

Repair or replace an appliance?

Beyond the numbers: safety, efficiency, parts and warranty.

Compare

Compare electricity separately

Energy savings are a separate estimate from the repair-cost rule of thumb. Use annual kWh and your own electricity rate to compare options, then account for extra purchase and installation cost. A comparison horizon is not a lifespan prediction, and a positive savings estimate does not justify operating an unsafe appliance.

Electricity costs and label guidance

Water differences and complete purchase quotes

Compare water use using documented gallons per cycle at the same workload, and keep variable water/sewer charges separate from fixed fees. For a replacement quote, add only extra delivery, installation, removal, parts and quoted tax not included elsewhere. Neither calculation supplies a lifespan or predicts future repairs.

Water and upfront purchase calculators

Related codes & guides