Past half of its expected life and the repair costs over half the price of a new unit — replace; otherwise a repair usually pays off
Many error codes end with a simple fix — a clean filter, a straightened hose. When the code points to a pump, a motor, a sensor or a control board, you get a repair quote and a decision to make. Two numbers do most of the work: how much of a new unit's price the repair costs, and how much of its expected life the appliance has already used.
Repair and replace compared
Repair
Replace
Upfront cost
Usually lower
Full price of a new unit plus delivery and installation
When it makes sense
Young appliance, repair well under half the new price
Old appliance, repair over half the new price
Energy and water use
Stays the same
Can drop with a newer efficient model — compare ENERGY STAR labels
Warranty
Usually only on the repaired part
New full manufacturer warranty
Hassle
One service visit, if parts are in stock
Shopping, delivery, removal of the old unit
Repair
Best when
The appliance is in the first half of its life, the quote is well under half the new price and the rest of the machine is in good shape.
Watch out for
A second failure soon after — ask the technician about the condition of the other major parts.
Replace
Best when
The appliance is old, the repair is expensive, parts are hard to get or it has failed several times.
Watch out for
Buying the cheapest model in a hurry; compare capacity, features and efficiency.
Bottom line
Use the 50 percent rule as a starting point, then adjust for warranty, efficiency and the condition of the rest of the appliance. Safety issues — a gas leak, burned wiring, a leak that soaked the floor — always come first.
Repair vs replace calculator
Enter the age, the expected lifespan, the quote and the new price — get the numbers in seconds.
Energy savings are a separate estimate from the repair-cost rule of thumb. Use annual kWh and your own electricity rate to compare options, then account for extra purchase and installation cost. A comparison horizon is not a lifespan prediction, and a positive savings estimate does not justify operating an unsafe appliance.
Annual kWh, per-cycle kWh and standby watts describe different measurement boundaries. The cycle tool adds variable water and sewer charges, the standby tool uses a defined idle schedule, and the time-of-use tool compares peak and off-peak energy shares. None supplies a model consumption figure or predicts savings from unsafe operating changes.
Compare water use using documented gallons per cycle at the same workload, and keep variable water/sewer charges separate from fixed fees. For a replacement quote, add only extra delivery, installation, removal, parts and quoted tax not included elsewhere. Neither calculation supplies a lifespan or predicts future repairs.